Showing posts with label motor sport. Show all posts
Showing posts with label motor sport. Show all posts

Sunday, May 1, 2011

2005 Kawasaki ZX-10R Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.
Roberti turned his fastest laps on the Kawasaki ZX-10R.
The hooligan of this crew was once again the nimblest on the track, though it comes at a price. Kawasaki has tamed the ZX's front end a bit, but the addition of a steering damper would have made some of us less less nervous. Roberti was unperturbed and set his quickest time on the rowdy ZX.
Kawasaki ZX-10R 2nd Place (89.0%)

The ZX is the wild animal of the group, and whether that's off-putting or desirable is up to you.

While the CBR was deemed rider friendly, the ZX-10R is rompin' ready. Its compact riding position received the highest scores in this test, and each time it was taken out on the track it was accompanied by mouth-watering anticipation and a healthy level of respect. It plays high-proof tequila to Honda's wine cooler.

"Last year the ZX wooed me to the dark side with raw power and the promise of feeling like a superhero waiting at the apex of every turn," says the comic-book minded Hutchison. "This year it feels more stable thanks to its revised suspension, but it's still a handful on the track."

Once again, the Kawasaki is the only one of the group not to be equipped from the factory with a steering damper. The 10R's suspension modifications outlined in our street test calmed the bike's nervousness under acceleration, but the test notes from our riders all mentioned a hesitancy to make full use of the ZX's stunning power.

"Laying down huge doses of power as you roll on the gas, the front end wants to lift even though you are still laid over," Chamberlain warns. "It's not a huge deal until you combine the light front end with rough pavement and a lack of a steering damper. Then you get headshakes."

"I never got a violent headshake," says Hutchison, "but it definitely let me know it wanted to get crazy on me."

Roberti noted the ZX's riding position, which he deemed "too high", might be contributing to its tendency to unweight its front end, as we noted during dragstrip testing in our street test. This condition results in a rider being unable to use full throttle in parts of the two lowest gears.

"You definitely have to be careful with this thing because it can quickly get out of shape on the throttle," Becklin adds. "The motor is strong enough to wheelie just about everywhere - even at high speeds."

What the lightest-in-class ZX-10 lacks in stability it makes up for in unrivaled agility. This is the sharpest-steering tool of the group, and it never has any trouble tightening its line. This was especially notable in PIR's tight infield section, where the max g recorded was second only to the amazing Ducati.

BC would ve selected the ZX-10 again in his For My Money if it had a steering damper.
The ZX-10R's motor is no less impressive in the face of the new Gixxer. It managed to out-class the competition down the back straight at PIR, clocking the quickest trap speed of 168.2 mph.
"The bike turns in extremely quick and is very stable through mid-corner," says BC. "It has the lightest feel up front of all the bikes," Roberti chimes in. "It feels very compact and racy and turns in quickly." And Becklin noted the ZX's riding position puts its rider up over the front-end which aids confidence when entering corners and feeling for traction.

Helping corner entries is the ZX's slipper clutch, which greatly eases downshifts by limiting compression braking, known in mechanical terms as "back-torque." The system, a first on production literbikes last year and now joined by the Suzuki for '05, allows its rider to be less concerned about perfectly matching revs when downshifting we had enough to worry about inside PIR's concrete walls. Interestingly, the ZX exhibited more compression braking from its motor than did the slipper-equipped Gixxer.

Our Vbox showed the ZX-10R to have the highest trap speed on the front straight thanks to its mighty motor, just edging the equally powerful GSX-R with an actual 168.2 mph. The Kawi's radial-mount brake calipers and petal-shaped discs bled off 100 mph in time for Turn 1, exhibiting strong braking that was judged by our riders to be right up with the best four-cylinder bikes. However, the Vbox data from Roberti showed the ZX actually pulled less g under braking than the rest. Your mileage may vary.

What this all adds up to was Roberti's quickest time around PIR. And despite all our wussy concerns about headshake, our fastest guy experienced none.

It's fair to say the Kawasaki is one of our favorites to ride thanks to its nuclear reactor motor, scythe-like handling and a willingness to go out and play - up to a point. When it came time to extract the next couple of tenths around the track, the rest of us had some trepidation about cracking its throttle to its stops. Those of us without the courage and smoothness of Roberti lapped quicker on other bikes.

"This bike is a rocket but really needs a steering damper to complete the package," says Becklin, no slow guy himself. "The front end is just too nervous on the gas to make the rider feel confident it isn't going to ruin his world."

"Although the ZX is as good as or better than the other bikes in every other way, the lack of this simple-bolt on accessory is enough to keep it from the top of my score sheet," BC says succinctly.

2005 Suzuki GSX-R1000 Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.

Ken chose the  05 Suzuki GSX-R1000 as his pick of the in-line fours.
The '05 GSX-R is a terrific package that won the street portion of our shootout, and it brought that same winning 'tude to the racetrack.
Suzuki GSX-R1000 - 1st Place (92.4%)

The winner in the street category of this comparison is no less armed to do battle against the rest of the contenders at the racetrack. Blessed with nimble yet stable handling, a powerplant that's the equal of the compelling lump in the ZX-10R, and the most enviable racetrack history of any Japanese model line, the Gixxer Thou comes out swinging a very big stick.

Since we're discussing motorcycles, let's begin with the Gixxer's motor. In a nutshell, it doesn't get better than this. Perhaps Becklin said it best.

"Power down low: great. Power in the midrange: great. Power up top: great. Power is great. The most impressive part is the pull you get from one corner to the next. Sure the top-end rush is cool, but this thing can get you from the end of one bend to the start of another almost as fast as your brain can handle."

Yep, only the truly brave and speed-addled won't be satisfied with this titanium-valved monster mill. "I swear, the devil lives on the last quarter-inch of the Suzuki throttle cable," Becklin adds. "When you pull the trigger, you best be prepared."

No less impressive is the Gixxer's driveline, which was given nearly universal high marks for the way its transmission gears mesh from one to the next, with or without assistance from its clutch. And speaking of clutches, the GSX-R's slipper unit works at least as well as the Kawi's, leaving one less thing to worry about when caning this hyperbike.

One small aspect of the GSX-R that became bigger by its numerous mentions concerned its riding position. It's not that it's bad, per se, just different. Everyone mentioned how its pegs are less rear-set than the others and, combined with its low seat height and narrow bars, it felt slightly odd.

"The GSX-R's pegs were placed too far forward and the bars are tucked in and swept back a little too much for my liking," BC quibbles. While Chamberlain's gripe centers around how the bike feels, Roberti believes its clip-on placement actually has a performance disadvantage. "The handlebars are narrow so it's hard to get leverage," says the Fast One. "I could've gone faster on it if its bars were wider." Evidence of this comes from Roberti's Vbox data that shows the Gixxer ranked fourth in terms of maximum lateral g-force in right-hand corners.

Although the Gixxer didn t log the best lap time at PIR  it was the quickest way down the quarter-mile.
Although the Gixxer didn't log the best lap time at PIR, it was the quickest way down the quarter-mile.
That aside, the Gixxer received high marks for its handling prowess, as it provides the best balance between high- and low-speed cornering capabilities. It's nearly as quick in tight corners as the ZX and pales behind only the train-stable 999R in the fast stuff. This GSX-R is both responsive and obedient.

"The bike was agile entering corners and stable as you carved though them," says BC.

"I was impressed with the GSX-R's ability to change direction mid-corner," DB jumps in. "I got into corners too hot several times and the Suzuki would just take my overly excited steering inputs in stride and get me back where I needed to be."

"The strong point on its chassis and suspension is the front-end feel and stability," Becklin continues. "I never felt uncomfortable with what the front was going to do. You get a lot of feedback from the front tire, and that's comforting on a bike this quick."

Braking is yet another area in which the Gixxer excels. Their power and feel were judged to be the best of the Japanese brands, and Roberti says the low Cg of the rider/bike package helped it maintain stability when braking heavily.

The only thing resembling a problem with the Suzuki was its appetite for rubber. Its back tire was balling up heavily under the abuse of 153 horsepower, and both Becklin and Roberti complained about a lack of rear grip.

2005 Ducati 999R Comparison

legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.
This year s MCUSA fantasy football champion almost didn t get to ride in this test  but Korf gave up his seat so Big Mike could ride.
The 999R proved it belonged with the best in the class with a superb track performance at Portland International Raceway.
Ducati 999R 3rd Place (87.6%)

Down at least a dozen ponies and several tenths in the quarter-mile, you wouldn't think the underpowered Duc would be able to compete on PIR's power-demanding dragstrip front straight.

Wrong, sushi breath. There's a reason why Ducati has dominated decades worth of World Superbike competition, and all that good stuff is represented in Ducati's racing platform, the 999R.

It's got nearly all the race-spec hardware you could mention, including titanium valves and rods, adjustable triple-clamps, carbon fiber fairing, a pricey and highly adjustable suspension, and an overall feel that makes its rider think he's sitting on the front row of the grid at Monza.

"I was amazed at the fact that the 999R could keep pace with the big Fours on a fast track like Portland," says Becklin. "Even though it's down on top-end speed, that torquey grunt gets it out of the corners well enough to run right with the other bikes."

Keep pace with the Fours? Yep. We were all shocked when we looked at Roberti's lap timer and saw that it was only four-tenths off the quickest time run all day. Perhaps even more impressive, it lapped quicker than two of the four-cylinders in this class. Test rider Mike Mitchell cut his quickest lap on the Duc, though he didn't get equal time on all the bikes.

And when your snooty Ducati friends tell you their bike corners like it's on rails, believe them. The 999R recorded the highest g readings on our Vbox in both right and left turns at PIR.

Each of our testers marveled at how well the Duc's power was able to be applied coming out of PIR's corners, and we were much more confident dialing up the throttle than on the other peakier bikes in this group. It's not nearly as intimidating when dialing on the power while still leaned over. "You could really put the power to the ground," Roberti raves.

Don warms up the 999R s tires for Roberti during data acquisition testing.
Even though it runs with the Big Four from across the Pacific, the 999R's hefty price tag makes it tough to justify picking it over one of the others. Still, if you've got the money to throw down, you'll be in riding nirvana.
"Its motor has great grunt from turn to turn and a surprising amount of top-end speed," Becklin notes. "I was able to stay in the draft of most of the other bikes." The Duc is aided aerodynamically by a narrow front profile and a short fuel tank that allows a rider to tuck behind the short windscreen. Although its accelerative g force ranked dead last in this group, its top speed down the front straight was down only 4-7 mph on the more powerful Fours.

The 999R also awed mightily while scrubbing off speed for the corners, and its 4-piston, 4-pad Brembo calipers emerged as the best in class. They recorded the highest negative g value on our Vbox under braking when about 100-mph of speed needs to be shed before tipping into PIR's Turn 1. No matter how hot we entered, the 999R's brakes shrugged it off with plenty of margin for error. These binders are probably the most potent we've ever experienced on a streetbike.

"The braking power of the Ducati was absolutely unbelievable," says Roberti, "but only an experienced rider can really tap the potential these brakes have to offer."

Ducati's most expensive model impressed us in the turns at a level we've previously never known from a V-Twin. Forged aluminum wheels give it an agility that would make an RC51 snort like a swine, and its highly evolved trellis frame gives it composure that is unsurpassed. It feels wonderful banked over in corners, like gracefully carving a line while water skiing on a smooth lake. It rewards a smooth rider yet copes nicely with an aggressive one. Roberti says it's the most stable and has the most precise front-end feel, and he noted its exemplary ability to hold a line on very fast turns.

Its one handling caveat is its tendency to stand up under braking. While this might surprise an unsuspecting rider, it becomes tolerable once accustomed to.

The Duc's Ohlins suspension was as good as you'd expect from the pricey Swedish dampers, with plenty of adjustment latitude. Despite the transmission's long throws, it was judged to have shifted smoothly and with precision. We liked the quarter-turn fairing fasteners and quick-release turnsignals, and we know its race-spec motor responds well to modifications. A buddy of ours bolted on a pipe and a Power Commander to uncork a significant 20 horsepower out of his 999R, bumping it up to 153 hp and 82 lb-ft of torque, which makes it more powerful overall than the stock Fours.

Ducati s super-trick superbike the 999R almost had what it takes to defeat the in-lines.
Despite the fact that it was down on top-end speed, the 999R's torquey nature allowed it to get out of the corners more quickly than the rest of the machines in our test.
One aspect of the 999R that disappointed was its instrument cluster that has no redline indicated. "It's nice with the big ol' tach front and center, but you have to learn where the rev limit is and then make up your own redline," Becklin whines. "I guess we could have put a piece of duct tape at 10,500 rpm, but that seems a little cheesy on a $30K bike." And for that price we might also expect a slipper clutch.

In the end, our group was somewhat torn on how to rank the Ducati. While it certainly impressed us with its ability to run with the big dogs, its $29,995 MSRP makes it difficult to compare.

"I would call the 999R confidence inspiring except that it's worth $30K and all you think about is trying not to crash the damn thing," says Becklin, the guy ultimately responsible for writing any crash-damage checks. "Roberti and (test rider Mike) Mitchell scared the shit out of me when they were laying down the hot laps." You could buy a Suzuki SV650 for what the R's carbon bodywork costs to replace.

Yep, the 999R is a unique piece of Italian machinery that almost defies comparison. It's not the fastest thing on two wheels, but it's one of the most desirable.

"Sure, you can buy three of the others instead of this one, but who in their right mind would want three Corvettes instead of one Ferrari?" Hutch asks in his own inimitable way. "The vibes that come from deep within the Ducati is that little extra something that it offers which the others cannot. If you have the cash for this bike, you probably have a specific bike for the street. If not, at least your one bike will be unbelievable."

2005 Honda CBR1000RR Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.
Becklin does his best to move the Honda up in the ranks by turning his fastest lap on the ebony beast.
The CBR was judged easiest to get comfortable on. However, its lack of top-end punch left our riders craving more power from Big Red.
Honda CBR1000RR 4th Place (82.6%)

Honda's literbike was awarded the distinction (dubious or not) of being the best superbike for newbies in our street test, and that feeling was reinforced during our time with it at PIR.

"The CBR was definitely the easiest bike to go fast on," Becklin affirms. "That's not to say it's the fastest, but it was easier to get it up to the limit without fearing for your life. It almost reminded me of riding a 600 - except for the weight - because it wasn't very intimidating to go quickly on."

Most riders praised the CBR's riding position, and Roberti judged it as the easiest to become comfortable on. In a similar vein, we were all comforted by the CBR's excellent stability, second only to the beautifully sorted 999R. While the higher horsepower ZX and GSX-R continually threaten to loft their front wheels, the milder CBR was able to lay down its power without second thoughts.

"The CBR may be down a few ponies, but I think I was able to be more generous with the amount of throttle exiting corners and probably got more power to the ground than I did on some of the other higher horsepower bikes," says BC.

The CBR's muscular midrange gives it a strong drive out of the corners, but it eventually gets run down by the other Fours in this test. It hits its rev limiter before a dyno-measured 12,000 rpm while the others continue winding out. Its trap speed of 166.3 mph was the slowest of the Fours (though not far off), and its peak acceleration was a distant fourth.

The CBR's only power delivery flaw shows itself when re-applying throttle from a closed position. "An abrupt throttle delivery is the only thing I found a little unnerving," BC notes, "especially when trying to be extremely smooth when traction is an issue."

You'd have a hard time guessing it from riding on the street, but the CBR is easily the heaviest bike in this group. It scales in a massive 31 pounds more than the class lightweight ZX-10R, and that extra lard makes itself noticeable on the track where performance demands are greater.

"I could definitely feel the weight of the CBR," Becklin asserts. "It didn't bother me too much, but it took more muscle to turn and it wouldn't hold a line very well when really pushed into a corner." That said, Becklin actually cut his quickest lap on the CBR, though the fact that he owns a 1000RR and has ridden it at PIR makes reading too much into this a bit suspect.

You ll find that Duke got a load of photo time while riding the CBR1000.
The CBR is easily the heaviest bike in the Smackdown, weighing in 31 pounds more than the lightest bike of the bunch, the ZX-10R.
"The bike did feel a little wide and heavy on turn-in," BC interjects, "But I think the weight showed most when getting the bike slowed from top speed."

Becklin concurs and adds, "Its brakes are the weakest in the class. There is a significant amount of lever travel before the brakes engage, and then slowing the bike down takes longer than the others."

Despite how the brakes feel to the rider, the CBR's vaunted stability helped the bike record the second-highest g under maximum braking at the track. Having the only non-radial-pump brake master cylinder may have contributed to the impression of lesser brakes as much as the CBR's extra weight.

Both Becklin and Roberti, our two fastest guys, noted the CBR tended to run wide on corner exits. "It runs wide every lap in Turn 1 and on the back straight," says Roberti, although slower riders were less aware of this condition.

Greater mass also takes its toll when converting energy into speed, and the CBR ultimately ended up with Roberti's slowest lap of the group.

"It's a very smooth and stable bike ideally suited for newer riders getting their confidence up on the track," Chamberlain opines, "but is too heavy and lacks the agility and horsepower for the serious racer."

"Honda has built what is arguably the easiest open-class bike to ride in the history of 1000cc bikes, yet it doesn't win on the performance sheets," Hutchison sums up. "The suspension is spot-on and the CBR's uncanny ability to stay planted makes it easy to say only good stuff about this machine. But I think it's too heavy to be the definitive track bike. In the end the CBR1000RR is a true streetbike that can hold its own at the track."

2005 Superbike Smackdown II Track


A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.
Monday, May 16, 2005



2005 Superbike Smackdown II Track
Okay, by now you've probably read the street portion of our 2005 Superbike Smackdown. In this exemplary crop of literbikes, Suzuki's new GSX-R1000 scored highest in a street environment thanks to the best powertrain in the group and an amazing lack of flaws.

But what if you don't give a damn about things like wind protection, seating comfort, mirror effectiveness and a heavy clutch pull? You just want to know how this 730-horsepower quintet sorts itself out in the no-limits environment of a racetrack.

Well, that's why we've been separating our track testing from the street results, allowing you guys to sort out for yourselves how important each category is to you and to weight them accordingly. We've created a separate scorecard for the track on which our testers rate each bike in 10 categories, and the results can be seen on the last page of this test.

As usual, we also offer MCUSA's "For My Money" section in which our test riders throw objectivity out the window and judge each bike based solely on personal preference. Comparing your skill level and experience to that of our testers might help you make a better decision about which bike is best for you. Despite a by-the-numbers winner rising to the top, it wasn't the only bike chosen by our individual staffers.

For this test, we wanted a place that would highlight the awe-inspiring power of the literbikes, so we decided to head to Portland International Raceway and its 3200-foot front straight, where the speedometers of a few bikes in our test displayed more than 180 mph!

We gathered our usual collection of testers who have had plenty of racetrack experience, and forced Korf at gunpoint to video our action. We also invited along one of the PIR's legendary champions, Shawn Roberti, who has assisted us with our other racetrack comparison testing. Roberti knows his way around PIR, so we knew we'd be getting lap times fully representative of each bike's capabilities and not just a quick time from the bike he went out on last.

All five test riders in rank-and-file while filming on-bike video. Ken leads the pack into turn 7 on the CBR1000RR.
Portland International Raceway was the scene of our track test. Long straights offered the opportunity to see what this quintet was really capable of doing.
Lap times were logged all day on our new MyChron Light TG Lap Timers from AIM Sports so we wouldn't miss any of Roberti's fast laps during the open trackday. We also strapped on our Vbox data acquisition system for some hot laps with Roberti, so we are able to bring you information about how hard each bike accelerated, slowed, cornered and maxed out its speed on the front straight.

We planned on two days of testing and using one of the new sets of race-compound DOT tires now available, but neither happened. Rain spoiled our first day at the track, and the tires that were originally promised became suddenly unavailable. Instead we reverted to the same Dunlop D208GPs that impressed us during our 2005 Supersport Shootout and adjusted each bike to suit.

Okay, that's the setup to what became a spine-tingling, nerve-raising, butt-clenching experience riding these hellacious maulers in the confines of a concrete-lined runway. Sick speeds, sweaty brows and big smiles ensued.

Turn the page to find out which bike finished fifth, and then keep turning until you get to the winner of MCUSA's Superbike Smackdown 2 Track Edition.

2005 Yamaha YZF-R1 Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.

Ken  BC and Duke run 1-2-3.  I must ve been lapping them -KD
The R1 had difficulty distinguishing itself from this talented group and falls to fifth in track portion of our second annual Superbike Smackdown
Yamaha YZF-R1 5th Place (78.6%)

In last year's Superbike Smackdown, it pained us to rank the gorgeous and capable R1 behind the ZX and CBR. Now, without a dated GSX-R to kick around, it sinks another spot. Still we feel pain.

I clocked in my quickest lap of the day, not coincidentally, on my last session after I was finally getting a handle on the track layout. My mount? The R1, and I had to wonder to myself, "Wow! How could a bike so powerful, stable and well-braked not be at the top of the pack?"

Well, the R1 is by no means a dog. It only falls short in one key area: midrange power.

"Just like on the street, the R1 is hurt by its lack of low-end and mid-range power," says Brian Chamberlain, our graphics guru and an amateur racer. "Luckily on the track you are usually up in the rev range, so the power deficiency down low is not as much of an issue, but it is still a little lackluster when driving out of corners. Throttle response is also a little abrupt, but not as severe as the CBR."

"It has good power on top, and it was a ripper when in the upper part of the rev band," adds Don Becklin, MCUSA president and a former expert racer. "But the low-to-midrange was weak compared to the other bikes."

The R1's cockpit is generally well laid out, but opinions varied among our testers of its effectiveness. It's roomy and comfortable on the track, but its pegs are mounted low and drag earliest.

"I found the ergos comfy and roomy enough for my 6-foot skeleton to tuck in easily," says BC, "although I'm finding the shorter reach to the bars on some of the other bikes more to my liking."

From its saddle, the slim-midsectioned R1 feels long, but its short, flat tank helps give the impression of a smaller bike. Becklin found fault with the R1's wide but short windscreen, saying that riders taller than 5-foot-ten should probably be looking toward the aftermarket for options. "Windscreen," asks Roberti. What windscreen?"

DB also had an issue with the handgrips on the R1. "The grips seemed fat for my smallish hands," he says, cautioning us not to read anything into that. "Luckily I'm so brave that the thought of my hands flying off the bars didn't even scare me," he adds with typical modesty. Some of us also noticed the Yamaha's stiff throttle-return spring, which sometimes made those off/on throttle transitions a bit tricky.

The Yamaha R1 may have come in last but the bike is so beautiful and so close to the others that we felt bad for making it this year s loser.
We hate to rank the thrilling R1 last; Yamaha's performance tour de force is a riot on the tarmac.
In action, the R1 feels bigger, heavier and slower-steering than all but the Honda, though its composure at speed is generous.

"The R1 is very stable," BC notes. "Although it doesn't flick in as quickly as some, it does provide a very confidence inspiring turn-in and turn exit." Roberti echoes Chamberlain's comments, adding that he believes the Yamaha has the best front-end feel among the Japanese bikes.

"I liked the fact that the R1 was uncannily stable," Becklin elaborates. "It was a good compromise between the too-sluggish Honda and ultra-quick Suzuki and Kawasaki. While stability was top-notch, it did seem to be sluggish on turn-in. You really had to muscle it into the corners, but once there it was good to go. I like the wider handlebars that makes getting the R1 turned a little easier this is just about the only bike I wouldn't push the bars out a bit."

There truly is nothing really wrong with the R1. It accelerates like a mother up top, as its highest longitudinal data demonstrates, and it is without any obvious flaws when railing the curves. The R1's scores are competitive in nearly every category, though it does rack up the bulk of the low rankings. It falls significantly behind in just two categories: its low-to-midrange power and its transmission, as the R1 was the only bike to have negative comments voiced against its gearbox.

"It seems strange to say about such a fast bike, but the R1 just doesn't have the same grunt as the Gixxer and ZX," editorial director Ken Hutchison sums up. "And when you combine that with a vanilla performance from the gearbox and other vital components, it places this bike in the middle of the road."

2004 Kawasaki ZX-10R Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.

Kawasaki ZX-10R
MCUSA's award for the best literbike for the street sits menacingly in gravel, waiting for its next victim.
With this raging quartet, the performance differences on the road are nearly insignificant. A street rider would have to be both brave and foolish to find them. And that's why we are taking this band on tour Laguna Seca, in particular to delve a little deeper into the ultimate performance limits of this incredibly talented group.

But fear not, those who want a winner to be declared.

And the award goes to

Kawasaki ZX-10R is MCUSA's pick for the best open-class sportbike (street category). And we weren't just blinded by its big power and tiny size. Just as in our Supersport Shootout last year, we gave each bike marks in 10 different categories, with the most important aspects given double the weight.

When the marks had been tallied, the ZX-10R had gathered the highest point total and garnered a 93% rating. It's superbike-fast, very sure-footed, looks bad-ass and makes its rider feel as if he rules the roads. What more can you want from a literbike?

Coming in second with an 85% rating is Yamaha's stunning R1. Part of the streetbike game is about looking good c'mon, admit it and the R1 is one sharp machine. Whether it's the angular bodywork, the sweetly-sick controlled-fill cast swingarm, or the Jimmy Durante nose that looks like a cross between an eagle and T2, the R1 proudly says that it is something special. The fact that you can pull up the front end at 120 mph and rail through the sweepers like a racebike are just really big bonuses to the R1's appeal.
2004 Kawasaki ZX-10R Highs & Lows
Highs
  • Dyno numbers and pulse rates!
  • Pint-size literbike
  • Scrappy personality
Lows
  • Too-tall gearing
  • Style points
  • Chances of keeping your license
One of the stand-out pieces on the CBR1000RR is its techno-tricky electronically controlled steering damper, and that's why Honda's new marvel fell to third in the rankings with an 81% score. If the neatest thing about a brand-new 1000cc sportbike is a steering damper (that works marvelously, btw), then somehow it's failed. The CBR gets strong scores in every category except for its "grin factor." It just doesn't excite and enthrall like its podium-mates. But that's not because of a lack of capability, and we wouldn't be surprised to see the CBR be right up there with the fastest times at Laguna Seca. Keep in mind, though, that the ZX-10 has a 12% better power-to-weight ratio than the hefty Honda.

Conclsion

With a 77% score, the GSX-R1000 slots into last place. If we were scoring this test on just empirical data, the venerable Gixxer Thou would score highly. Its combination of gearing, torque and an excellent clutch might give it top marks in acceleration contests, and its sure-footed handling will keep things close on the racetrack. But this is a streetbike test, and the old guard looks like it is a step behind until next year, at least. Its swingarm looks like it was cobbled in the Daytona pits compared to the artfully crafted Unit Pro-Link gleaming unpainted on the Honda, and its cockpit looks like a Kia next to the Audi-like R1. And it feels fat.

Boasting power-to-weight ratios that would make a million-dollar Ferrari Enzo envious, we would never consider labeling any of these bikes as a loser. The fact of the matter is they're all extraordinary vehicles with performance levels that are stratospheric. They're actually more machine than most riders can handle, but we think that's part of their appeal.

"I want one," said one of our loyal message board posters, SV650TN, about the R1. "I don't care if I do highside into Arizona. I still want one."

"Even if you're doing a 3-minute lap on a 2-minute track, the ZX-10 makes you feel cool," Hutchison said upon returning from Homestead. We now can understand: it makes you feel cool on the street, too.

Makes ya wonder what's going to happen at the track, donnit?

Share your thoughts on the '04 Superbike Shootout in the MCUSA Forum. Click Here

2004 Honda CBR1000RR Comparison

A legend in the motorcycle industry, Duke Danger is known for his wheelie riding antics, excellent writing skills, appetite for press intro dinners and a propensity to wake up late. Once a fearless member of the MotoUSA team, the Canadian kid is often missed but never forgotten.
2004 Superbike Smackdown Street
The front end of the Honda inspired confidence in me, probably due to the steering damper. The ergos felt a little aggressive - pegs were slightly higher, a little more pressure on the wrists, and seat was a little firmer. รข€“Brian Chamberlain, MCUSA VP of creative design.
Fat is Sexy?

When we first tested Honda's CBR1000RR, it impressed with its large and linear powerband and unflappable stability. Those things still hold true, but the new CBR is so well polished that it was difficult to get a good feel for how it should slot it into the class pecking order.

The only obvious pimple concerning the RR is the pull of gravity on its considerable mass. With its fuel tank empty, the CBR scales in at 433 pounds, a full 30 pounds more than the anorexic Kawasaki and 15 pounds heavier than the R1, the second pudgiest of the group.

I think we're seeing a pattern here. First, routing an exhaust system up and under the seat, with its attendant shielding and bracketry, is the inverse equivalent of the Wonder Bra: It makes the bike look trim but makes it heavier in actuality. Compared to the ZX-10, the CBR carries an extra 15 pounds on its rear wheel alone. The similarly piped R1 weighs in just three pounds more than the old GSX-R, and you just know that Suzuki is going to lop off about 10 pounds for its all-new 2005 model.

Secondly, even the engineering might of Honda has trouble keeping the weight down on its newer RR models. First the 600RR was heavier than the F4i, and now the CBR1000RR is porkier than the 954RR. While the underseat exhaust plays a role in the added heft, some blame must also go to Honda's innovative Unit Pro-Link rear suspension. Honda says incorporating both ends of the rear shock inside the MotoGP-inspired swingarm isolates the main frame/chassis from forces acting on the rear suspension, and we think they may be on to something there. But until they develop the technology further, we can expect the Honda RR series to be at a slight weight disadvantage.

If you were to ride only the Honda, you'd swear it is the best sportbike ever made, such is the way it has been polished to Honda's typical high standards. The CBR, with so many of the rough edges shaved off, would get our vote as the Least Exciting Superbike of 2004. We're not sure how Honda can build a 150-hp race-bred machine and make it feel as if a dozen ponies slept in on the day of the stampede. The RR will challenge wheelie hounds more than the three other excellent unicyclers, and it felt almost anemic at 7000 feet of elevation.

CBR1000RR
Heated seats on both the Honda and the Yamaha are courtesy of underseat mufflers, as is a lack of storage space. The things we do for fashion.
Which isn't to say the Honda is slow. You'd have to be Miguel Duhamel to feel that 148 hp and 76 lb-ft of torque isn't enough. But it's the stepless way the CBR produces its power that had us waiting for the "hit" that never came. Of course, if the sole goal from your rides is to get through a canyon road as quickly as possible without breaking a sweat, the RR is perhaps the perfect ally, even if it is a little less willing to change directions. It's stable as a train, even leaned over in the bumps, and its grunty motor mostly out-torques even the muscular ZX up to about 9000 rpm.

The CBR performs less well on the open road. Although its Showa fork is plush and responsive, discomfort sets in on longer rides because of a thinly padded seat and a persistent vibration at certain cruising speeds that buzzes pegs and bars to the extent that a few of our testers' hands went numb. The CBR's not exactly up to De Sade levels of torture, but it and the R1 would be the last picks when going out for a 500-mile day.

Lap Times

2004 Honda CBR1000RR Highs & Lows
Highs
  • Refinement
  • Easy to ride fast
  • Billet-like stability
Lows
  • Least exciting superbike
  • Jenny Craig candidate
  • Where’s the hit?
By now you might've noticed a distinct lack of racetrack photography and were wondering how long you'd have to read before you got to the lap times and quarter-mile results. Well, your read won't be much longer but your wait is.

For the first time, we decided to split a sportbike comparison test in two. We hear you guys out there who say they don't care if one bike is 0.3-second quicker around Willow Springs that has little relevance to those who never even see a racetrack.

This is the reason we haven't spoken about ultimate handling limits and which bike has the best brakes. Know what? They'll go around corners faster than most of us would dare, and with 4-piston radial-mount brakes on each bike, there is little distinction between them in street use.